Free live business consulting every Friday at 6:30 pm ET. RSVP →
Contact

Why Aren't Your Cold Emails Getting Responses?

Why Aren't Your Cold Emails Getting Responses?

It might not be your approach yet. Cold email is a numbers game, so two emails isn't enough to tell. When I audit cold campaigns, it's usually one of two things: the email sounds too professional, or it's too long and too wordy.

How many cold emails to send before you judge your approach

Someone asked me at Friday Strategy Sips about cold pitches. She had sent two, heard nothing back, and wondered if her approach was wrong.

With two, I would say, let's talk about it at 25 emails.

It's really a numbers game. So maybe your approach was wrong, but maybe it wasn't.

From Friday Strategy Sips: Your cold emails sound too PROFESSIONAL

The 2 reasons cold emails don't get responses

What I find when I'm auditing people's cold campaigns, and a few people called this week and we went through it, is one of two things.

  1. It sounds too professional. Relax your tone a ton, more than feels professional to you. Just take it down a notch.
  2. It's too long and too wordy. I'm talking 2 sentences for the first paragraph, 2 sentences for the second one, maybe a bullet or two, and wrap it up.

If you can get those two down, keep it really simple.

Why a cold email should get straight to the point

Cold email is completely different from warm email. With cold emails, we don't introduce the brand and say hello. We get straight to the point and try to get them to convert.

Warm people have seen you, they know you, they love you, they've downloaded a freebie. You can nurture them and be real nice and sweet. Cold, you send into the inbox and immediately state what you need and want: hey, I saw that you needed this, our firm does this, period. Then you follow up, and it's more aggressive. Don't treat cold like warm.

Conclusion

Before you decide cold email doesn't work, send enough of them to know. Then make them shorter, more relaxed, and straight to the point.

Have a question you need answered? Every Friday at 6:30 PM Eastern, I do free live business consulting at Friday Strategy Sips. Just show up and ask.

FAQ

FAQs About Cold Email Responses

How many cold emails should you send before changing your approach?

Two isn't enough to tell. Let's talk about it at 25. Cold email is really a numbers game.

What's the most common cold email mistake?

It sounds too professional. Relax your tone a ton, more than feels professional to you.

How long should a cold email be?

Short. 2 sentences for the first paragraph, 2 for the second, maybe a bullet or two, and wrap it up.

Should a cold email introduce your brand?

No. Get straight to the point: I saw that you needed this, our firm does this. Save the nurturing for warm leads.

Should you follow up on cold emails?

Yes. Follow up, and cold follow-up is more aggressive than warm.

Tierra Wilson, AI & Business Growth Consultant for service-based businesses

About the author

Tierra Wilson

Tierra Wilson is an AI & Business Growth Consultant for service-based businesses with 15 years in tech, 500+ clients, and consulting credits with Google, MyFitnessPal, Under Armour, Hewlett-Packard, USPS, and GoDaddy. She's a founding member of the Google Small Business Advisory Board and a former GoDaddy Pro Council member. She also runs AiBT Advisory, an AI deployment firm for mid-market companies.

Everything on this blog comes from real experience running real service-based businesses.

More about Tee

I'm here

want to talk through this?

If you read this and have questions about how it applies to your business, I'm happy to chat. Book 30 minutes and tell me what you're working on.

Book 30 minutes